Lost Tale: “The Coming of Tsathoggua” (1951) by Herman Stowell King

In the early days of organized fantasy, weird, and science fiction fandom, “fan fiction” was simply fiction by fans for fans, published in fanzines without compensation, to differentiate it from the fiction published professionally in pulp and slick magazines, newspapers, etc. Early fan fiction may have had an amateurish quality, but it wasn’t explicitly based on the works of other writers, or include characters and settings from other works. Mythos stories, however, were an exception; they emerged quite naturally beginning in the 1930s, from poetry like & “The Woods of Averoigne” (1934) by Grace Stillman, “Shadow Over Innsmouth” (1942) by Virginia Anderson, and “The Acolytes” (1946) by Lilith Lorraine, and short fiction like “The Picture” (1939) by Robert D. Harris. The Mythos was open to exploration and exploitation in a way many more consolidated properties were not at the time.

Herman Stowell King (1929-2015) was a science fiction fan and collector, known mostly today for his fanfiction and poetry and a few other pieces published in magazines like Fate and Exploring the Unknown. His particular contribution to the Cthulhu Mythos seems unusually overlooked.

First published in Peon #17 (January 1951).

※

The Coming of Tsathoggua

by Herman Stowell King

Far back in the pre-existence of manking, when Earth was still a steaming morass, and the first weird life form crawled forth from the ooze of primal slime, the god Tsathoggua came through the void from a distant planet called Cykranosh (now termed as Saturn by astronomers). Tsathoggua was an evil god; he had lived for interminable eons of time, and Cykranosh was not his original home. Vicenillions of years ago, he had come there from a remote star, in a galaxy so distant as to be unthinkable.

In appearance, Tsathoggua somewhat resembled a huge, bloated toad, although he was not batrachian in the least. His skin, and again we must use a mundane analogy totally adverse from the real thing, was covered with a short, sloth-like fur. There were no pupils in his bulging eyes, and his nose was almost bridgeless. His body was moist and slimy: composed of some viscid, protoplastic substance.

Now although Tsathoggua was extremely repulsive in every aspect, he was an incredibly wise god. He held secrets that a normal terrestrial mind could not begin to conceive; knowledge of extra-cosmic galaxies, multiple dimensions, primordial races of ultimate evolution, the creation of the elements; this, and more, he knew, and could be drawn from wells of the subconscious should he ever have use for such wisdom.

Tsathoggua, however, had more than one attribute of the toad. Aside from quasi-physical resemblance, he was sluggishly lazy. The long journey from Cykranosh (although infinitesimally small in comparison with the one from his original habitat) had tired him, and after gorging on a few amphibian creatures, he burrowed deep in some hot, fetid muck, where for many milleniums he slept soundly.

The Earth had gone through a long stage of cooling and solidification; and the slime vanished from the surface to be replaced by warm seas. Green vegetation sprang up, and soon the land was covered with lush, tropical jungles. Living organisms went through various processes of evolution, and presently the earth teemed with tremendous animals, most of which were reptilian.

Dinosaurs roamed the jungles, and marshes, and pterodactyls flapped ugily though the air. Diplodocus fed on vegetables, while Tyrannosaurus fed on Diplodocus.

The god Tsathoggua was awakened by the cooling of the muck in which he was embedded. Lazily blinking his protuberant eyes (he had sight despite the lack of pupils—a fantastic extra-optical sense of perception) he wobbled elastically onto the dry ground, and proceeded to search about for means of nourishment.

The first living animal to impinge on Tsathoggua’s cognition was a flying Pteranodon. Displaying a remarkable elongation, the squat, drowsy-looking deity from outer space flicked out his tongue and viscously encircled the poor Pteranodon. There was an inarticulate squawk, and Tsathoggua gulped the reptilian bird down his plastic esophagus. Anon followed a period of digestion. Tsathoggua did not convert his food in the manner characteristic of homo sapiens and lesser animals; instead he merely assimilated it into his own individual substance. And considering his essence, there was no danger of over-expansion.

Having done with that small morsel, the toad god ran rubberly off, apparently awkward, but with amazing celerity. Entering the thick jungle he espied a huge, scaly-clad creature walking upright. Tyrannosaurus Rex, the most ferocious of all reptiles.

Surely, this enormous quadruped would satiate his hunger, thought Tsathoggua. Immediately, he waddled placidly toward the Tyrannosaurus, who after an interval of surprised silence (surprised that anything dared approach him) snorted a loud challenge. Eyes red with terrible wrath the battle-scarred carnivora of the Mesozoic Age bounded to meet his non-terrestrial adversary.

Tsathoggua quickly underwent a phenomenal metamorphosis, melting into a semi-liquid state, and literally pouring over the bewildered Rex! There was a short moment of violent convulsion, as the die-hard warrior struggled valiantly against the swallowing tide of tenacious life which engulfed him. All effort was futile however, and after a few feeble tremours, the lumpy mass of adhesively sticky matter remained motionless. It had not taken long for Tsathoggua to incorporate the scrawny Pterandon into himself, but the great Tyrannosaurus was a vastly different undertaking to him!

Hours later, following this extended absorption, Tsathoggua remolded back to his anurian likeness, and deciding he did not like the surface climate, commenced to seek some subterranean abode.

This proved an easy task for such an intelligent deity. By use of some recondite, extra sense, Tsathoggua located a suitable place deep in the bowels of the earth, the entrance being a narrow, volcanic fissure atop a black basaltic mountain.

So the god Tsathoggua found a residence agreeable for a long state of Earth existence. In this underground grotto he slept continuously, coming to the surface only occasionally for food; but usually he even transported his substance by exerting some subtle, psychokinetic energy, without moving physically from his spot of repose.

The ages unfolded as he drowsed; the Mesozoic giving way to the Tertiary, the Tertiary yielding to the Pleistocene, and so on. Man appeared on Earth, and civilization pushed back barbarism.

Vast empires graced the lands; Hyperborea and Atlantis with their fair cities rearing marble cupolas aloft; Mu and Valusia came and went, leaving naught but myth and legend of their existence. There was among those peoples a mystical few who worshipped Tsathoggua, and in return for their carnal tributes he gave them awful and marvellous powers of sorcery and necromancy. Having the wisdom of an elder god at the evocation, these wizards executed nameless foul deeds of evil and corruption. Through the performance of unholy rites and incantations, those that numbered the cult of Tsathoggua could control the elements, conjure up the dead, withstand mortality by regulating the metabolism in the protoplasm; in fact, there was little those devil worshippers could not do.

But as time passed, and all those wonderful civilizations vanished into limbo, so vanished man’s credulity in gods and all things considered immaterial, till finally there was no one to worship Tsathoggua, because no one believed he existed.

Very few were those who still sought pleasure in the form of strange and inexplicable pursuits, and the ones that did find Tsathoggua were woefully weak and pusillanimous, for they went mad at the knowledge of the toad god’s reality. Many of these never returned from the dark-lit grotto, but fell victim to his evil gluttony.

Yea, gone are Hyperborea and Atlantis; gone save in vague fables; but the god Tsathoggua still sleeps in his subterrene abode, and there shall come the time when he awakens voracious, and horror and havoc will descend on the cities of man.

※

Tyrannosaurs (late Cretaceous period, 69-66 million years ago) did not prey on Diplodocus (late Jurassic, 152-149 Ma). Nor did either co-exist with Pteranodon (late Cretaceous, 86-78 Ma). If I were glossing this, I would suggest that Tsathoggua had awoken in some remote region where various dinosaur species had continued to co-exist long after the period that paleontologists have assigned to them, like the Savage Land in Marvel Comics. That’s a quibble for a brief, very fannish piece.

Tsathoggua was the creation of Clark Ashton Smith, but because of the vicissitudes of pulp publishing, Lovecraft actually ended up mentioning Tsathoggua in print before Smith did. King was clearly drawing more on Smith’s interpretation of Tsathoggua than Lovecraft’s, but was synthesizing from disparate elements in the Mythos to put his little characterization together:

It’s from N’kai that frightful Tsathoggua came—you know, the amorphous, toad-like god-creature mentioned in the Pnakotic Manuscripts and the Necronomicon and the Commoriom myth-cycle preserved by the Atlantean high-priest Klarkash-Ton.
—H. P. Lovecraft, “The Whisperer in Darkness” (1931)

I had never seen an image of Tsathoggua before, but I recognized him without difficulty from the descriptions I had heard. He was very squat and pot-bellied, his head was more like that of a monstrous toad than a deity, and his whole body was covered with an imitation of short fur, giving somehow a vague suggestion of both the bat and the sloth. His sleepy lids were half-lowered over his globular eyes; and the tip of a queer tongue issued from his fat mouth. In truth, he was not a comely or personable sort of god, and I did not wonder at the cessation of his worship, which could only have appealed to very brutal and aboriginal men at any time.
—Clark Ashton Smith, “The Tale of Satampra Zeiros” (1931)

He had cultivated the acquaintance of Zhothaqquah, who, in the desuetude of his worship, was now driven to lead an existence wholly subterranean; he had offered the prescribed prayers, had made the sacrifices that were most acceptable; and the strange, sleepy little god, in return for Eibon’s interest and his devotion, had confided to him certain information that was more than useful in the practise of the black arts. Also he had presented Eibon with some autobiographical data that confirmed the popular legends in more explicit detail. For reasons which he did not specify, he had come to Earth in former aeons from the planet Cykranosh (the name by which Saturn was called in Mhu Thulan); and Cykranosh itself had been merely a waystation in his travels from remoter worlds and systems.
—Clark Ashton Smith, “The Door to Saturn” (1932)

Black Tsathoggua moulded itself from a toad-like gargoyle to a long, sinuous line with hundreds of rudimentary feet […]
—H. P. Lovecraft & Hazel Heald, “The Horror in the Museum” (1933)

Somewhere beneath that four-coned mountain, the sluggish and baleful god Tsathoggua, who had come down from Saturn in years immediately following the Earth’s creation, was fabled to reside […] You shall know Tsathoggua by his great girth and his batlike furriness and the look of a sleepy black toad which he has eternally. He will rise not from his place, even in the ravening of hunger, but will wait in divine slothfulness for the sacrifice. And, going close to Lord Tsathoggua, you must say to him: “I am the blood-offering sent by the sorcerer Ezdagor.’ Then, if it be his pleasure, Tsathoggua will avail himself of the offering.
—Clark Ashton Smith, “The Seven Geases” (1934)

[…] could turn a human Carter into one of those earlier entities which had dwelt in primal Hyperborea and worshipped black, plastic Tsathoggua after flying down from Kythanil, the double planet that once revolved around Arcturus […]
—H. P. Lovecraft & E. Hoffmann Price, “Through the Gates of the Silver Key” (1934)

It had been built in imitation of certain temples depicted in the vaults of Zin, to house a very terrible black toad-idol found in the red-litten world and called Tsathoggua in the Yothic manuscripts.
—H. P. Lovecraft & Zealia Bishop, “The Mound” (1940)

Like “Why Abdul Al Hazred Went Mad” (1950) by D. R. Smith, this is a fan filling in a piece of unwritten Mythos history. There’s not a lot in the way of plot in this short piece, but it’s a rare example of someone leaning more toward Clark Ashton Smith instead of Lovecraft in early Mythos fanfiction.

The Tsathoggua item threw us but not enough to make the issue as a whole suffer too much.
—Startling Stories Sep 1951


Bobby Derie is the author of Weird Talers: Essays on Robert E. Howard and Others and Sex and the Cthulhu Mythos.

Deep Cuts in a Lovecraftian Vein uses Amazon Associate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

“To Clark Ashton Smith” (1951) by Evelyn Thorne

TO CLARK ASHTON SMITH

I think quicksilver leaps along his veins,
And if you look too deeply in his eyes,
You’ll see behind the ice-thin laughter there
The smouldering glimpse of fateful sorceries.

I think that if you listen while he speaks
You’ll catch a foreign ac[c]ent on his tongue,
That hints a language built of stars and wine
A syntax all with fiery jewels strung.

I think that if you miss him some dark night
You should not be surprised or wonder where
He’s gone; look up, Arcturus greenly burns—
Do you not see him on that shining stair?
—Evelyn Thorne

The second issue of Alan H. Pestetsky and Michael DeAngelis’ fanzine Asmodeus (Fall 1951) was devoted primarily to Clark Ashton Smith. Lovecraft had been receiving accolades in The Acolyte in the 1940s, so it was only fair. The issue republished a poetic tribute by Lovecraft to his friend, as well as “The Cup-Bearer” (1951) by Lilith Lorraine, and buried among other works was the above dedication by Eveyln Thorne.

While she is mostly forgotten now, in the 1950s Evelyn Aixa Thorne was actively involved with science fiction fandom, not necessarily a Big Name Fan, but not insignificant either. A brief biographical essay in Poets in the South says she was born in Nebraska in 1898, educated in the College of Puget Sound and the University of Arizona, and lived all over the country “working as an interior decorator, an X-ray txnician, and a botancial illustrator” (78). She married William Richmond Tullos in 1946, they divorced in 1952, remarried in 1954, and remained married until his death in 1974.

Thorne is probably best-remembered as co-publisher/co-editor of the New Athenaeum Press with Will Tullos, which published Epos: A Quarterly of Poetry, from 1949 until 1975, which published three of Clark Ashton Smith’s poems. She was also associate-editor of Challenge (1950-1951) under Lilith Lorraine, who also published some of Thorne’s poetry elsewhere. Her books of poetry were Design in a Web (1955), Ways of Listening (1969), and Of Bones and Stars (1982); she also published anthologies of poetry from Epos.

There is a certain incestuous quality to fantastic poetry in the 1950s, an intersection between the “little magazine” movement and science fiction/fantasy fanzines which echos the intersection between amateur journalism and science fiction fandom in the 1930s. That Evelyn Thorne knew and appreciated Clark Ashton Smith as a poet is clear. The reference to “Arcturus” in particular is curious; Smith refered to Arcturus in three poems first published in The Star-Treader and Other Poems (1912): “To the Sun,” “The Song of a Comet,” and “Saturn”—all cosmic poems that echoed or were influenced by Smith’s mentor George Sterling’s “The Testimony of the Suns” (1903).

A detail Smith no doubt appreciated, when he read that tribute.


Bobby Derie is the author of  Weird Talers: Essays on Robert E. Howard and Others  and  Sex and the Cthulhu Mythos .

Deep Cuts in a Lovecraftian Vein uses Amazon Associate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

“The Cup-Bearer” (1951) by Lilith Lorraine

Lilith Lorraine, to whom I sent a copy of Out of Space and Time, writes that she will review the book in the January issue of her quarterly, The Raven. She is a kindred spirit, and highly appreciative, and I doubt if I’m likely to find a more favorable reviewer. Her poetry is splendid from what I have read of it.
—Clark Ashton Smith to August Derleth, 21 Nov 1943, Eccentric, Impractical Devils 341

Lilith Lorraine (Mary W. Wright) was a pulp fiction writer and poet contemporary with H. P. Lovecraft, Robert E. Howard, August Derleth, Clark Ashton Smith and the rest of the Weird Tales circle, but her handful of professional sales were in science fiction magazines such as Wonder Stories, and she didn’t begin to correspond with folks like Clark Ashton Smith and August Derleth until the 1950s, but she was active in science fiction fandom in the 1940s and 50s, supply poems for fanzines, books, magazines, etc. such as “The Acolytes” (1946). She also published her own poetry journals and issued collections of her work as well.

In Fall 1951, the fanzine Asmodeus published its second number, a special issue devoted to Clark Ashton Smith. Among the articles and poems was Lilith Lorraine’s poetic tribute to the Bard of Auburn:

The Cup-Bearer
(To Clark Ashton Smith)

The light of other worlds is in his eyes,
His voice is like a sunken temple chime,
And many a moon that sings before it dies
Has heard him in the catacombs of time

Such souls come only when the cycles close,
When the dark wine of ages mellowed long,
blends terribly the tiger and the rose,
Seraph and satyr, savagery and song.

Such souls come only when the dreamer wakes
Alone beneath a decomposing sky,
Before the dream dissolves in crystal flakes
To hold new lamps for gods to travel by.

And just before the old dream turns to dust,
He holds again the dark, delirious grail,
The lethean wine of loveliness and lust,
Of tenderness and terror; should he fail

The dream would vanish and the wavering world
Shorn of its wonder, shaken to the core
Back to the “Never-has-been” would be hurled. . . .
Sing with him softly, lest you sing no more.

As poetic tributes go, there is no doubt that Lilith Lorraine knew her subject well. “The Cup-Bearer” touches on many of the themes that are a hallmark of Smith’s poetry and fiction: satyrs (“Nyctalops”), seraphs (“The Ghoul and the Seraph”), wine (“The Tears of Lilith”), dreams (“The Hashish-Eater”), memory (“Lethe”), necromancy and necrophilia (“Necromancy”), and strange distant stars (“Lament of the Stars”). It is a fitting tribute, because it is of a piece with Smith’s work, and complements it.

Lilith Lorraine must have liked “The Cup-Bearer” well enough, for she included it in Wine of Wonder (1952), her thin collection of poetry on themes of poetry and science fiction. She wasn’t the only one. Various editors provided lengthy endorsements on the inside cover flap, and on the back:

The summer lightning of fantasy, the storm-piercing levin of imagination, illume these superbly wrought poems. Lilith Lorraine remembers the ancient wonder and magic, but walks intrepidly the ways that modern science has opened into the manifold infinites.

From the mystic lyric beauty of Termopolis and Only the Black Swan Knows, she turns to such clarion-like annunciations of things to be as Master Mechanic and The Matriarchs. Notable, too, for its plangent irony, is Post-Atomic Plea for Euthanasia. A searching and claivoyant sensitivity is shown in the poems on paintings by Dalí and George Gross. Not too often has one art been interpreted so revealingly in terms of another as in these magnificent verse.

WINE OF WONDER can be recommended unreservedly both to poetry lovers and deotees of scientific fiction. Seldom if ever have the Muses of lyricism and science united their two fold afflatus to a result so distinguished.
—CLARK ASHTON SMITH, Author of [Out of] Space and Time, widely known poet and science fiction author.

Lilith Lorraine is fascinating as an author who outside the normal circle of H. P. Lovecraft, Clark Ashton Smith and co., only to at occasional interval swoop in within their orbits, bright as a comet…and then out again, forgotten until once more she comes around. Yet hers was a fascinating career, and she deserves to be remembered.

Lorraine bio

Biographical page, date unknown, from the August Derleth collection at the Wisconsin Historical Society


Bobby Derie is the author of Weird Talers: Essays on Robert E. Howard and Others and Sex and the Cthulhu Mythos.

Deep Cuts in a Lovecraftian Vein uses Amazon Associate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

“The Man Who Sold Rope To The Gnoles” (1951) by Margaret St. Clair

A HYMN OF HATE

Margaret St. Clair, of Berkeley, California, writes: “I’ve been a good quiet uncomplainng reader of WEIRD TALES for about ten years—but the prospect of another story by Edmond Hamilton moves me to hysterical outcry. He makes me want to scream and bite my nails—’captured thirty-six suns’ indeed! His style is nothing but exclamation marks; his idea of drama is something involving a fantastic number of light-speeds; he is, in the words of one of my favorite comic strip characters, flies in my soup. He is science-fiction at its worst: all WEIRD TALES needs to make the science-fiction atmosphere perfect is a letter from Forrest J. Ackerman and a story by Hamilton. Oh, and another gripe—I dislike the blurbs you are printing at the first of the stories. They are just a waste of space. I hate vampire and werewolf stories—my blood refuses to congeal for any number of undead clammily hooting about. There was a time when I could be made to shiver by the mention of garlic, but now it’s just something to put in salad. Things like Shambleau are what I like. As long as WT prints stories by Clark Ashton Smith, however, I’ll keep on reading it. His tales have a rounded jewel-like self-containedness that is, artistically, a delight. … And Smith’s drawings are, I think, by far the best in the magazine. … In conclusion, Jules de Grandin is a pain in the neck.”
—WEIRD TALES, June 1934

Margaret St. Clair could be considered a peripheral member of the gang of writers commonly called “the Lovecraft Circle.” She met Clark Ashton Smith while a student at the University of California at Berkeley, and began corresponding with him as early as 1933. (Selected Letters of Clark Ashton Smith 208n1) St. Clair broke into the pulps after World War II, and her stories graced the pages of Weird Tales beginning in 1950, one of the last new voices to find a home at the magazine before its inevitable demise.

“The Man Who Sold Rope To The Gnoles” (first published in The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, Oct 1951), is one of Margaret St. Clair’s most famous stories. Her tale is inspired by and directly references Lord Dunsany’s own famous jocular fantasy “How Nuth Would Have Practiced His Art Upon the Gnoles” (The Book of Wonder, 1912). Dunsany was a substantial influence on Lovecraft’s early fiction, and some later writers have worked to tie the Lovecraft Mythos more directly to Dunsany, such as “My Boat” (1976) by Joanna Russ and “Meet Me on the Other Side” (2002) by Yvonne Navarro.

Margaret St. Clair is drawing directly from Dunsany here, pursuing her own homage to the British master of fantasy instead of trying to tie it into anything larger, expanding his Mythos but staying true to the spirit of the original story. There is something essential of Postwar America in the piece, a lightness of tone and a focus on money and its pursuit, with an ironic dark twist at the end reminiscent of Charles Addams’ The Addams Family and Robert Bloch’s light-hearted Mythos story “Philtre Tip” (1961).

Nuth looked on for a while from the corner of the house with a mild surprise on his face as he rubbed his chin, for the trick of the holes in the trees was new to him; then he stole nimbly away through the dreadful wood.
—Lord Dunsany, “How Nuth Would Have Practiced His Art Upon The Gnoles”

The gnoles were watching him through the holes they had bored in the trunks of trees; it is an artful custom of theirs to which the prime authority on gnoles attests.
—Margaret St. Clair, “The Man Who Sold Rope To The Gnoles”

Dunsany has inspired any number of writers, Lovecraft not least among them. The error most writers make is trying to write like Dunsany, to capture something of his style. Like pasticheurs who ape the cosmetic aspects of Lovecraft’s prose and miss the deeper stylistic structures, themes, and philosophical underpinnings which make his fiction work. St. Clair here does not attempt pastiche, but homage: she pays reverence to Dunsany’s story and the details he gave, while writing her own, in her own voice.

Which is why this is one of the few “Dunsanian” stories which works.

It is not by any stretch of the imagination a story that Dunsany would have written, which is half the point. J. R. R. Tolkien once criticized Dunsany’s story “The Distressing Tale of Thangobrind the Jeweller”, also published in The Book of Wonder, lamenting:

Dunsany at his worst. Trying so hard for the shudder. But not for a moment making the tale ‘credible’ enough

Whether or not Dunsany was trying for a shudder or a chuckle, readers can decide for themselves. St. Clair by contrast was militantly angling for the lighter side, and the way in which she does so showcases, perhaps, how closely allied some of Lovecraft’s style of hinting was to Dunsany’s:

It was the parlor the gnole led him to. Mortensen’s eyes widened as he looked around it. There were whatnots in the corners, and cabinets of curiosities, and on the fretwork table an album with gilded hasps; who knows whose pictures were in it?
—Margaret St. Clair, “The Man Who Sold Rope To The Gnoles”

The juxtaposition of the Gnoles, strange and terrible as they are, having a very British or American-style parlor full of knickknacks and an album is the same sort of intimate contrast of “the fields we know” and the exotic and impossible which is such a hallmark of Dunsany’s early work. St. Clair’s leading question is in line with the unspoken horrors which Tolkien was so displeased with and which Lovecraft often used to such great effect: letting the reader’s imagination fill in the blanks.

The gnoles, it seemed, would be regular customers; and after the gnoles, why should he not try the Gibbelins? They too must have a need for rope. (ibid.)

“The Hoard of the Gibbelins” immediately proceeds “Gnoles” in The Book of Wonder, and St. Clair’s references to it in this story could have been a step toward stitching together some of Dunsany’s standalone stories into something like a larger Mythos, though she never pursued such a design. It is something readers of Lovecraft take almost for granted—didn’t Lovecraft borrow elements from Dunsany, Arthur Machen, Robert W. Chambers (and Chambers himself from Ambrose Bierce)?

Certainly Margaret St. Clair, who was reading Weird Tales so early and so long, knew what she was doing.


Bobby Derie is the author of Weird Talers: Essays on Robert E. Howard & Others (2019) and Sex and the Cthulhu Mythos (2014).